#Immich does not have 2FA and the devs made clear, it's not coming.
-
@fbinin @hrafnagud @panda @homelab But a good TOTP implementation takes some effort too if you want to support multiple devices and recovery codes. The library updates are probably not because of TOTP itself, the might be required due to the libraries dependencies or framework integrations. Furthermore, if TOTP is implemented, why not add WebAuthn/Passkeys too?
@tandemblog @hrafnagud @panda @homelab
1 at a time tbvh.
I mean TOTP first, so that at least the basic need is implemented. Rest can come at a later stage if possible. The more ask gets chipped, the more the word NO gets chanted by the devs.I do understand it all can be done. It also begs the question of a maintainer. Even smaller changes or updates at times may break something. One reason why I said, just implement the basis TOTP at least.
-
@fbinin @hrafnagud @panda @homelab Furthermore I like to manage my credentials and MFA settings in one place instead of in multiple applications. My services a home grew to the point I already have 14 applications using Keycloak as OTP service. Additionally a Single Sign On requires less support for family members. (I'm aware not every one wants to operate so many applications)
@tandemblog @hrafnagud @panda @homelab
Very true. Not everyone likes to have so many things. I have 40+ TOTPs myself. -
@preya @panda @homelab Ah, right. Now I remember what the issue was (it's been a long time since I last looked into this but my browser history showed what I had been looking into):
https://odd.blog/2026/01/16/creating-a-shared-photo-library-in-immich/
"While Immich has shared albums, they don’t quite solve this problem. The photos don’t appear in search and aren’t processed for face recognition or analysis."
The article proposes a solution based on an external library. That's why I still remembered this "solution"...
-
@preya @panda @homelab Ah, right. Now I remember what the issue was (it's been a long time since I last looked into this but my browser history showed what I had been looking into):
https://odd.blog/2026/01/16/creating-a-shared-photo-library-in-immich/
"While Immich has shared albums, they don’t quite solve this problem. The photos don’t appear in search and aren’t processed for face recognition or analysis."
The article proposes a solution based on an external library. That's why I still remembered this "solution"...
-
-
@abulling @vb @preya @panda @donncha Just in case you want to track this, note that this seems to be the #1 item in the Immich roadmap (not that I think order is that important): https://immich.app/roadmap
And is being tracked here: https://github.com/immich-app/immich/issues/12614I haven't decided yet on Immich vs Ente Photos here.
-
-
@thedoctor @vb @preya @panda @homelab @donncha Tried it as well. Didn't like it either.
Immich is by far the most promising/nice looking software for this in my opinion. But (so far) it still lacks several features that unfortunately prevent me from switching to it completely.
We need user groups - otherwise sharing albums etc is a nightmare once you have more than a handful of people using it.
And shared albums should offer the same functionality as "normal" ones. I don't want to have duplicates or miss out images that show a particular person because Immich can't run duplicate/face detection in shared albums.
-
@preya @panda @homelab Ah, right. Now I remember what the issue was (it's been a long time since I last looked into this but my browser history showed what I had been looking into):
https://odd.blog/2026/01/16/creating-a-shared-photo-library-in-immich/
"While Immich has shared albums, they don’t quite solve this problem. The photos don’t appear in search and aren’t processed for face recognition or analysis."
The article proposes a solution based on an external library. That's why I still remembered this "solution"...
@abulling
I think the immich fork Noodle improves this. -
@abulling
I think the immich fork Noodle improves this. -
M mjack@mastodon.bsd.cafe shared this topic
