One of the common misnomers around the migration away from toxic tech stacks is that the options are either 1) services managed by a company or 2) everyone #selfhosting themselves.
-
@JulianOliver we moved from rocket chat to matrix 2 yr ago. we have alot of groups. some with over 1k+ users. Our userbase is 60+. it works. Not saying it is all smooth. but mattermost is us based, and isnt real open. you have to pay the http://sso.tax/ ... yea the nice ui ... ok but element is getting there. the element X app is so good!
remarkable, that in your sphere of influence, UX is more important than opsec to you. why?@xr1st0ph The opsec with Mattermost is great when self-hosted & push notifications running through your own push server. Metadata quiet on the wire & FLOSS (team edition).
Again, we have deployed Matrix for groups, but IME it is a higher risk migration target with more ontraining req. Many are coming from Slack too, so for this case esp MM is by far the smoother journey.
If tech-averse get cold feet they will never move again & stay on US bigtech.
You either listen to people or you lose them
-
@xr1st0ph The opsec with Mattermost is great when self-hosted & push notifications running through your own push server. Metadata quiet on the wire & FLOSS (team edition).
Again, we have deployed Matrix for groups, but IME it is a higher risk migration target with more ontraining req. Many are coming from Slack too, so for this case esp MM is by far the smoother journey.
If tech-averse get cold feet they will never move again & stay on US bigtech.
You either listen to people or you lose them
@xr1st0ph I use Matrix every day btw (with Element). As for SSO, we urge groups that choose MM to steer clear of it. Rather 2FA to email, ideally at their selfhosted MTA.
However some employ OAuth2 for auth flow from selfhosted platforms like GitLab, Nextcloud etc. This can work very well.
-
@xr1st0ph Can compile that out easily if handy with Go, or just use the drop in binary from Frama:
@JulianOliver there is no active upstream or someone maintaining this. thats honestly cant be a good or safe way for infrastructure.
-
@xr1st0ph The opsec with Mattermost is great when self-hosted & push notifications running through your own push server. Metadata quiet on the wire & FLOSS (team edition).
Again, we have deployed Matrix for groups, but IME it is a higher risk migration target with more ontraining req. Many are coming from Slack too, so for this case esp MM is by far the smoother journey.
If tech-averse get cold feet they will never move again & stay on US bigtech.
You either listen to people or you lose them
@JulianOliver thats kindof true. but you really only have to convince a small group and the rest will follow.
No E2EE in Mattermost would be a no go in infra for activism for me. people should and must learn how to protect their communictaion. You should educate not lower the bar.
Make some youtube videos and a good wiki entry and people will use it or ask someone. my experience.We proclaim it as a WhatsApp replacement, and it works well. people help out each other.
-
@xr1st0ph I use Matrix every day btw (with Element). As for SSO, we urge groups that choose MM to steer clear of it. Rather 2FA to email, ideally at their selfhosted MTA.
However some employ OAuth2 for auth flow from selfhosted platforms like GitLab, Nextcloud etc. This can work very well.
@JulianOliver yea there is this hack right? is it still possible to use the gitlab in the teams version for some keycloak i.e.?
-
@JulianOliver there is no active upstream or someone maintaining this. thats honestly cant be a good or safe way for infrastructure.
@xr1st0ph It's just a few lines and a diff quickly shows it's gtg. If concerned about the fork, just grab the source, patch and compile. Takes a few mins.
Even so, Framasoft have a longstanding great rep.
-
@xr1st0ph It's just a few lines and a diff quickly shows it's gtg. If concerned about the fork, just grab the source, patch and compile. Takes a few mins.
Even so, Framasoft have a longstanding great rep.
@JulianOliver sure. but something like this adds up in DevOps and administration. How anyone can tell this will work next year? or the apps will get this limit to? i will definitly not compiling android and ios apps by hand everytoime an update hits. how to distribute?
Shouldnt this be taken in concideration when using such a fork? -
@JulianOliver thats kindof true. but you really only have to convince a small group and the rest will follow.
No E2EE in Mattermost would be a no go in infra for activism for me. people should and must learn how to protect their communictaion. You should educate not lower the bar.
Make some youtube videos and a good wiki entry and people will use it or ask someone. my experience.We proclaim it as a WhatsApp replacement, and it works well. people help out each other.
@xr1st0ph If a group using WhatsApp &/or Slack &/or Teams trials your alt & they don't bite despite your efforts to educate, you go with 2nd best bc it's better than no migration.
Every week I work with groups on migration plans, educating, & one rule sticks: you cannot force people.
BTW if a group trusts their sysadmin(s), the machine is FDE AES-XTS/LUKS2 and tightly locked down in a rack or on-prem, E2EE affordances at the service layer are practically meaningless in most threat models.
-
@xr1st0ph If a group using WhatsApp &/or Slack &/or Teams trials your alt & they don't bite despite your efforts to educate, you go with 2nd best bc it's better than no migration.
Every week I work with groups on migration plans, educating, & one rule sticks: you cannot force people.
BTW if a group trusts their sysadmin(s), the machine is FDE AES-XTS/LUKS2 and tightly locked down in a rack or on-prem, E2EE affordances at the service layer are practically meaningless in most threat models.
@xr1st0ph You can have E2EE up to your ears and it's futile if the end-point is powered on (even with FBE) & in the hands of adversary. This is by far the biggest threat to frontline activism I see almost daily with those insisting on taking phones to protests. Chats exposed, Signal, MM, Matrix, does not matter. If you don't have a path and means to centrally disable accounts all is lost. Signal is very troubled like this. The group admin removes arrested from the group, but prior chat remains
-
@xr1st0ph If a group using WhatsApp &/or Slack &/or Teams trials your alt & they don't bite despite your efforts to educate, you go with 2nd best bc it's better than no migration.
Every week I work with groups on migration plans, educating, & one rule sticks: you cannot force people.
BTW if a group trusts their sysadmin(s), the machine is FDE AES-XTS/LUKS2 and tightly locked down in a rack or on-prem, E2EE affordances at the service layer are practically meaningless in most threat models.
@JulianOliver normally people who fight for a good cause never despite anything imho and xp.
thats true and this is why you use matrix. the element admin app is exactly for that: remove all tokens and shut down the app for a specific user. even if someone has now access to the phones storage, its all E2EE with no way of getting those messages. you can even deice forceing a reset of all messages.
-
@JulianOliver sure. but something like this adds up in DevOps and administration. How anyone can tell this will work next year? or the apps will get this limit to? i will definitly not compiling android and ios apps by hand everytoime an update hits. how to distribute?
Shouldnt this be taken in concideration when using such a fork?@xr1st0ph All the official apps work fine. I use patched MM server (the MM Go binary) on a bunch of instances.
-
@xr1st0ph All the official apps work fine. I use patched MM server (the MM Go binary) on a bunch of instances.
@JulianOliver thats not my why of doing things. out activists and i go the extra mile. but i think its great that it works for you.
-
@JulianOliver thats not my why of doing things. out activists and i go the extra mile. but i think its great that it works for you.
@xr1st0ph We work very hard at this, and have been at it for years. Nonetheless, you may be better at convincing groups to use tools you think they should use than we are.
We find trying to convince folk is not always the wisest end game. Rather, a compromise is sometimes necessary for a successful staged migration away from jurisdictionally or materially compromised services, with outcomes of higher platform morale, so lower chance of regression &/or splintering, & better overall org opsec.
-
@xr1st0ph We work very hard at this, and have been at it for years. Nonetheless, you may be better at convincing groups to use tools you think they should use than we are.
We find trying to convince folk is not always the wisest end game. Rather, a compromise is sometimes necessary for a successful staged migration away from jurisdictionally or materially compromised services, with outcomes of higher platform morale, so lower chance of regression &/or splintering, & better overall org opsec.
@JulianOliver THIS!
Are you interrested in a videocall? taking this further? I would love to learn something about your work.
-
@JulianOliver normally people who fight for a good cause never despite anything imho and xp.
thats true and this is why you use matrix. the element admin app is exactly for that: remove all tokens and shut down the app for a specific user. even if someone has now access to the phones storage, its all E2EE with no way of getting those messages. you can even deice forceing a reset of all messages.
@xr1st0ph I am well aware. This is a feature I like both in MM and Matrix.
I am not the one to convince.
-
@xr1st0ph I am well aware. This is a feature I like both in MM and Matrix.
I am not the one to convince.
@xr1st0ph In summary, Mattermost also has its problems, in particular the dumbing down of finer-grained admin controls to push people to Enterprise. The seat limit is also absurd and patronising.
Matrix with Element (X) however has UX issues that while not a big issue for those more enthusiastic about tech, they can be total breaking points for the tech and/or migration averse. Some of the gripes here I heard verbatim from climate activists we trialed on Matrix: https://xn--gckvb8fzb.com/giving-up-on-element-and-matrixorg/
-
One of the common misnomers around the migration away from toxic tech stacks is that the options are either 1) services managed by a company or 2) everyone #selfhosting themselves.
There is however an often overlooked 3rd option of community-scaled infrastructure. Here a group identifies their needs, plans & deploys to meet them. Much like a community garden, that infrastructure has people skilled & dedicated to its upkeep in providing for that group, working bees & skillshare as needed.
1/n
@JulianOliver
There are organizations doing community IT infrastructure in various forms: @datacoop @deuxfleurs @konstellationen and several others. There's a matrix room for exchanging ideas, anyone working on something like this DM me and I'll get you in touch with the admins. -
N niels@social.data.coop shared this topic
