With all the tiktok drama I have been telling people Mastodon is still here and kicking!!
-
With all the tiktok drama I have been telling people Mastodon is still here and kicking!! I love this app and I really think the decentralized model is the best for social media.
Still, people don’t want to join! What do you think Mastodon’s biggest barriers are to courting new users? What could be done to improve the product and grow the user base in a positive way?
@taylorlorenz It lacks an addictive algorithm.
-
@taylorlorenz It lacks an addictive algorithm.
I think the way we make DIY discovery eg build your own algorithm so mandatory makes it hard for the fedi to fulfill the role of social media in many people's lives: a way to relax ... social media functions a lot like how people have watched TV for decades. "just to see what's on"
I think there is nothing wrong with algorithms as long as they are transparent, and created by users.
-
With all the tiktok drama I have been telling people Mastodon is still here and kicking!! I love this app and I really think the decentralized model is the best for social media.
Still, people don’t want to join! What do you think Mastodon’s biggest barriers are to courting new users? What could be done to improve the product and grow the user base in a positive way?
@taylorlorenz
“At this historical moment, I’d value the fact that Mastodon is made in the #europeanunion. I’m a new user myself who joined as part of a Trump-led US boycott campaign, so I was looking for a #EU-made alternative—Mastodon seemed like the most structured one anyway.
#EU #buyeuropean we should follow the Canadians’ example #buycanadian” -
I think the way we make DIY discovery eg build your own algorithm so mandatory makes it hard for the fedi to fulfill the role of social media in many people's lives: a way to relax ... social media functions a lot like how people have watched TV for decades. "just to see what's on"
I think there is nothing wrong with algorithms as long as they are transparent, and created by users.
What if we had a kind of mini-app where users could create their own algorithms and then share combine and trade them?
I might design a mix of hashtags, users, and hand picked posts and call it "Ant News" someone else might pick a group of users and hash tags and create "Italian Football Bloopers"
Then we could share and rate these feeds and new users could just click on the popular ones?
-
What if we had a kind of mini-app where users could create their own algorithms and then share combine and trade them?
I might design a mix of hashtags, users, and hand picked posts and call it "Ant News" someone else might pick a group of users and hash tags and create "Italian Football Bloopers"
Then we could share and rate these feeds and new users could just click on the popular ones?
I think this could possibly be built into the mastodon lists feature
-
What if we had a kind of mini-app where users could create their own algorithms and then share combine and trade them?
I might design a mix of hashtags, users, and hand picked posts and call it "Ant News" someone else might pick a group of users and hash tags and create "Italian Football Bloopers"
Then we could share and rate these feeds and new users could just click on the popular ones?
A feed creation tool could have options such as:
* Include/exclude these hash tags
* Include/exclude these users... but only if -- condition is met.
* Always pull a post with an image from, for example -- talented artist/photographer
* Never show two posts from the same user in a row.
* Include trending posts, but only if it's not/is "US pol" (for example)Make a tool to design an algo, let us give them cute names, let people vote and argue about which ones are the best.
-
What if we had a kind of mini-app where users could create their own algorithms and then share combine and trade them?
I might design a mix of hashtags, users, and hand picked posts and call it "Ant News" someone else might pick a group of users and hash tags and create "Italian Football Bloopers"
Then we could share and rate these feeds and new users could just click on the popular ones?
@futurebird @aurochs Yahoo Pipes was awesome!
-
@taylorlorenz I think famous people need to get on here, most people I've spoken with regarding Mastodon or Fediverse is that they follow news and gossip mostly on the commercial platforms.
If the people come, the people will follow
I think this is true. People often respond to those who point this out by saying "but that's the whole problem with modern culture, famous people aren't cool, etc etc." And I even agree.
But, I'd still like to know what my favorite SF authors, politicians, musicians, interesting journalist etc. have to say.
That was part of the fun of Twitter at its best.
-
What if we had a kind of mini-app where users could create their own algorithms and then share combine and trade them?
I might design a mix of hashtags, users, and hand picked posts and call it "Ant News" someone else might pick a group of users and hash tags and create "Italian Football Bloopers"
Then we could share and rate these feeds and new users could just click on the popular ones?
@futurebird@sauropods.win @aurochs@todon.eu I like that. I think people should then also be able to opt-in to a "thing" where they also sporadically get posts that aren't in any of their chosen feeds, but are "related", for example by virtue of being in the feeds of the some of the people they follow, to give the sense of serendipitous discovery of new stuff. Maybe, a somehow tunable "serendipity factor" that widens the concept "related".
I think a tab like tab would usually be more useful/interesting than the local/global timelines. -
@NicksWorld @anja @taylorlorenz reading through this thread and I think we need more things to make it seem cool. Marketing is a good idea. Also, I don’t know how easy it is to build on top of mastodon’s API, my understanding of twitter’s initial rise was openness of the api and the developer ecosystem that created was a big part of adding cool new features.
@ryebreadnyc @anja @taylorlorenz I am not a programmer so my knowledge is limited. If its easy to do, that'll most definitely help.
-
With all the tiktok drama I have been telling people Mastodon is still here and kicking!! I love this app and I really think the decentralized model is the best for social media.
Still, people don’t want to join! What do you think Mastodon’s biggest barriers are to courting new users? What could be done to improve the product and grow the user base in a positive way?
@taylorlorenz Mastodon's biggest barrier is network effect, a budget to attract users, and it not being, or wanting to be, the new Twitter. Bluesky has the first two, which has given it the advantage on the first, but not yet enough to overtake old Twitter.
The future for Mastodon is to continue not being the next Twitter, but pull in users that should naturally prefer decentralized and non-profit, like government organizations and sane people. That and journalists adding it to their byline. -
@futurebird@sauropods.win @aurochs@todon.eu I like that. I think people should then also be able to opt-in to a "thing" where they also sporadically get posts that aren't in any of their chosen feeds, but are "related", for example by virtue of being in the feeds of the some of the people they follow, to give the sense of serendipitous discovery of new stuff. Maybe, a somehow tunable "serendipity factor" that widens the concept "related".
I think a tab like tab would usually be more useful/interesting than the local/global timelines.@futurebird@sauropods.win @aurochs@todon.eu this latter thing could possibly be a client thing? I don't know enough about the tech behind mastodon and activitypub to say. -
@futurebird@sauropods.win @aurochs@todon.eu I like that. I think people should then also be able to opt-in to a "thing" where they also sporadically get posts that aren't in any of their chosen feeds, but are "related", for example by virtue of being in the feeds of the some of the people they follow, to give the sense of serendipitous discovery of new stuff. Maybe, a somehow tunable "serendipity factor" that widens the concept "related".
I think a tab like tab would usually be more useful/interesting than the local/global timelines.I would love it if there were a feed with more funny posts. You know like dril tweet type content.
I'm very happy about the complex issues and deep discussions but sometimes I'd just like to see some nonsense.
-
With all the tiktok drama I have been telling people Mastodon is still here and kicking!! I love this app and I really think the decentralized model is the best for social media.
Still, people don’t want to join! What do you think Mastodon’s biggest barriers are to courting new users? What could be done to improve the product and grow the user base in a positive way?
@taylorlorenz Lack of search. Inability to click on a user’s follows/following and see who they follow/are following.
-
@taylorlorenz i think at heart, most people don't want to out in that much effort to lurk. I wonder what proportion of social media use is passive consumption.
@RowinSpeez @taylorlorenz@mastodon.social A lot, it's why the algorithmically controlled services do well. They give you a constant stream of things to read or watch, that's why they keep people around as it's basically passive and encourages attention-seeking in those who do create. The fediverse as a whole though doesn't have that, there's no rewards and involvement is encouraged as it gives what you put in. Don't do much with it, it won't give much but do more with it and it'll reveal itself to you somewhat like encouraging a seedling into a fully mature plant.
I still use the Trending sections of a few instances just to see what the pulse is and that can vary depending on how big an instance is, how generous the members are with boosts and likes and what that instance's interests are. Still very useful though if you're looking for diamonds in the rough.
-
A feed creation tool could have options such as:
* Include/exclude these hash tags
* Include/exclude these users... but only if -- condition is met.
* Always pull a post with an image from, for example -- talented artist/photographer
* Never show two posts from the same user in a row.
* Include trending posts, but only if it's not/is "US pol" (for example)Make a tool to design an algo, let us give them cute names, let people vote and argue about which ones are the best.
@futurebird@sauropods.win @aurochs@todon.eu that sounds similar to misskey antennas, but those don't really work for me and I don't know why. -
Curating content is real work. Tiktok didn't talk about it a lot but they put a great deal of effort into making the first experience users had with the app fun.
Showing them things they'd never seen before that were funny, or exciting ... using the spy data to tailor it to the particular user. Using the way the user scrolled to improve that experience.
-
Curating content is real work. Tiktok didn't talk about it a lot but they put a great deal of effort into making the first experience users had with the app fun.
Showing them things they'd never seen before that were funny, or exciting ... using the spy data to tailor it to the particular user. Using the way the user scrolled to improve that experience.
I think most people here find that kind of tracking and filtering a little creepy? But, it was also very convenient.
Over here we are like "follow two-dozen hash tags, and 300 people and then MAYBE your feed will be kind of interesting." Alternately? Here is the fire hose of your server's feed with 200 posts from the same person. Or the global feed which is just chaos.
Can we respect the art and craft of curating content? Can we make it a human thing?
-
@futurebird@sauropods.win @aurochs@todon.eu that sounds similar to misskey antennas, but those don't really work for me and I don't know why.
For better or worse mastodon has primary influence over what features are "really" a part of the fedi.
I feel they are far too adverse to change and stuck on pleasing existing users, not making the app, more accessible and popular.
There is this *false* idea that being popular is the same thing as being corporately captured, driven by a desire for profits, ads.
There are other good reasons to want your app to be fun and popular. Not esoteric and exclusive.
-
@taylorlorenz Lack of search. Inability to click on a user’s follows/following and see who they follow/are following.
@gloriousnoise @taylorlorenz I can view a user's follows/following.... (I'm just using the mobile website).
