Saying that you do not want GenAI in the #books you read, the things you watch or the games you play is an understandable and NORMAL position.
-
You keep mentioning fear of the machines.
Not about that.
You keep mentioning grammar checking and transcription functionality.
Not about that.
Look, we get it. AI sounds hot. We read the same science fiction books and it is nice to think that maybe one day LLM technology can be leveraged against oppression. News about fake open models are fun in a sense because every time one of those pops up, some idiot is going to lose millions yadda yadda. But you are missing a very important point here: a permission structure is being built around us, and stopping it is absolutely crucial
-
Look, we get it. AI sounds hot. We read the same science fiction books and it is nice to think that maybe one day LLM technology can be leveraged against oppression. News about fake open models are fun in a sense because every time one of those pops up, some idiot is going to lose millions yadda yadda. But you are missing a very important point here: a permission structure is being built around us, and stopping it is absolutely crucial
Every time you do a "both sides" stuff between "AI hypers and deniers" you are basically telling me that the person worried about the destruction of their life, their job and the environment has the level of delusion of a person like Peter Thiel, an eldritch horror in a vessel made of flesh that thinks humanity, umm, should not exist.
-
Every time you do a "both sides" stuff between "AI hypers and deniers" you are basically telling me that the person worried about the destruction of their life, their job and the environment has the level of delusion of a person like Peter Thiel, an eldritch horror in a vessel made of flesh that thinks humanity, umm, should not exist.
This is Mastodon. There is people here that can install GotoSocial in a smart oven toaster and then proceed to launch it in low orbit just for fun. Please stop making allusions to technophobia. It's irritating and disrespectful
-
This is Mastodon. There is people here that can install GotoSocial in a smart oven toaster and then proceed to launch it in low orbit just for fun. Please stop making allusions to technophobia. It's irritating and disrespectful
@berniethewordsmith Thank you for this outstanding thread. You've said everything I have wanted to say, but much more eloquently.
-
Every time you do a "both sides" stuff between "AI hypers and deniers" you are basically telling me that the person worried about the destruction of their life, their job and the environment has the level of delusion of a person like Peter Thiel, an eldritch horror in a vessel made of flesh that thinks humanity, umm, should not exist.
@berniethewordsmith might be good to include that you're talking about (american, big-tech) LLMs
We've used various forms of ML&AI for decades, everything from video-games to produce logistics and vaccine research. It's a group of technologies not singular thing (LLMs is not the whole group!)
-
Every time you do a "both sides" stuff between "AI hypers and deniers" you are basically telling me that the person worried about the destruction of their life, their job and the environment has the level of delusion of a person like Peter Thiel, an eldritch horror in a vessel made of flesh that thinks humanity, umm, should not exist.
@berniethewordsmith I am more worried about the absolute mediocre output of ai. For some it might be 'good enough' and that is ok. Please do understand that for most of us 'good enough' is just below our standards. Don't let an ai that is 'good enough' drive your car or have an ai that is 'good enough' do your finances. Accidents will happen and those accidents will be very costly.
-
@berniethewordsmith might be good to include that you're talking about (american, big-tech) LLMs
We've used various forms of ML&AI for decades, everything from video-games to produce logistics and vaccine research. It's a group of technologies not singular thing (LLMs is not the whole group!)
@iamada Yes, I am referring specifically to this kind of Generative AI that is trying to be shoehorned everywhere. Alien Isolation is a good example of an AI in a videogame that is absolutely incredible. AI slop is not
-
@berniethewordsmith Thank you for this outstanding thread. You've said everything I have wanted to say, but much more eloquently.
-
@berniethewordsmith might be good to include that you're talking about (american, big-tech) LLMs
We've used various forms of ML&AI for decades, everything from video-games to produce logistics and vaccine research. It's a group of technologies not singular thing (LLMs is not the whole group!)
@iamada
Machine Learning has been around for a while and is proven technology. Indeed not to be mistaken for LLM's.
@berniethewordsmith -
@berniethewordsmith I am more worried about the absolute mediocre output of ai. For some it might be 'good enough' and that is ok. Please do understand that for most of us 'good enough' is just below our standards. Don't let an ai that is 'good enough' drive your car or have an ai that is 'good enough' do your finances. Accidents will happen and those accidents will be very costly.
@alterelefant I also worry about this. There is certainly an effort to convince people to settle with "just ok" stuff
-
@iamada
Machine Learning has been around for a while and is proven technology. Indeed not to be mistaken for LLM's.
@berniethewordsmith@alterelefant @iamada Yeah, I'm definitely referring to this LLM in the soup nightmare we are currently in
-
@alterelefant @iamada Yeah, I'm definitely referring to this LLM in the soup nightmare we are currently in
@berniethewordsmith
The output of an LLM has to be thoroughly checked by a subject matter expert. Failing to do so will make things go south very quickly.
@iamada -
@alterelefant I also worry about this. There is certainly an effort to convince people to settle with "just ok" stuff
@berniethewordsmith That 'just ok' might work for certain cases and people also need to respect that it just doesn't work in other cases.
-
J jwcph@helvede.net shared this topic
-
@berniethewordsmith
The output of an LLM has to be thoroughly checked by a subject matter expert. Failing to do so will make things go south very quickly.
@iamada@iamada @alterelefant @berniethewordsmith which renders it useless. In fact worse than useless as time and effort of specialists is diverted from more useful work.
-
@iamada @alterelefant @berniethewordsmith which renders it useless. In fact worse than useless as time and effort of specialists is diverted from more useful work.
@seb321
In some cases it might save a couple of minutes here and there but it is definitely not the revolution they try to make us believe it is. At least if you value the quality and correctness of your work.
@iamada @berniethewordsmith -
@iamada @alterelefant @berniethewordsmith which renders it useless. In fact worse than useless as time and effort of specialists is diverted from more useful work.
@alterelefant @berniethewordsmith @iamada it reminds me of the scene in Blade Runner where Tyrell explains to Roy how his life is inhibited and any way around the inhibitor leads back to the same result. Any argument for how a flawed LLM can be used by human intervention renders the function obsolete.
-
Saying that you do not want GenAI in the #books you read, the things you watch or the games you play is an understandable and NORMAL position. Maybe they have ethical concerns, maybe they love their artist homies. Maybe they don't like the bland garbage that AI generates. Stop framing this like an horde of neoluddites is starting the Butlerian Jihad (would be fun doh) just because they do not want to follow a romance autor who has a computer shitting novels instead of writing them herself.
and bring back the people who make handwritten copies, stop guttenberg...
-
@berniethewordsmith That 'just ok' might work for certain cases and people also need to respect that it just doesn't work in other cases.
@alterelefant @berniethewordsmith Also, if the "just ok" books are being shat out at several times the rate of actual proper books that have been written by an actual writer, then they become a fire hose that drowns out the good books. It's not just romance, either. I came to the unpleasant realisation that I've recently read some psychological thrillers that are very probably AI-generated, with varying degrees of "author" edits to make them readable. Some of them were ok, albeit with some elements that didn't seem to work that well, one degenerated into an unholy mess for the last 20% of the "novel." I don't know exactly how many AI books I've read, as a lot of it comes down to the rate of publication being too high, and that can be hidden by the use of pseudonyms, or using different publishers. I don't really want to read books that people haven't bothered to write, either fully or in part, but it's going to become more difficult to do that.
-
@berniethewordsmith might be good to include that you're talking about (american, big-tech) LLMs
We've used various forms of ML&AI for decades, everything from video-games to produce logistics and vaccine research. It's a group of technologies not singular thing (LLMs is not the whole group!)
@iamada @berniethewordsmith
It's too late. Tech bros have co-opted the AI term. If you don't want to be confused for them, use more specific terms.Say pattern recognition, not AI.
Say grammar check, not AI.
Say NPC logic, not AI. -
Saying that you do not want GenAI in the #books you read, the things you watch or the games you play is an understandable and NORMAL position. Maybe they have ethical concerns, maybe they love their artist homies. Maybe they don't like the bland garbage that AI generates. Stop framing this like an horde of neoluddites is starting the Butlerian Jihad (would be fun doh) just because they do not want to follow a romance autor who has a computer shitting novels instead of writing them herself.
@berniethewordsmith Sure, at least today I completely agree. AI stories lack a lot compared to good human stories to the point it's a waste of time. That won't be any different for movies, tv, even web pages as it is. It's low effort junk.
At the same time, for writing code, AI is increasingly helpful.
