Once again I’m asking you; scribbly or polished?

[shadows_killer@mastodon.social]

@heyheymomo I also just noticed by the... eye? window? (Don't want to assume) placement on the forg house roof in each, but I think that only matters if you're a big fan of symmetry (which I am) and actively looking for details (which I was)

[blanche@piaille.fr]

@heyheymomo I really like both, but I prefer scribbly because it feels warmer and more full of life.

[avatastic@avatastic.uk]

@heyheymomo scribbit!

[kev@social.catastrophic.horse]

@heyheymomo scribbly feels right

[junezephier@blahaj.zone]

@heyheymomo@socel.net scribbly has maximum charm and naturally draws my eye more, but the polished font is nice to read :3

[obot50549535@left-bank.net]

@heyheymomo It concerns me that although I can see they are different, it took me quite some time to see which one is scribbly. I see it now.

[mini_ninja_64@chaos.social]

@heyheymomo scribby

[hexadecimal_bird_wizard@kind.social]

@heyheymomo Scribbly! it's more human/made-by-a-people looking and leans into the cute

[aj@androiddev.social]

@heyheymomo Scribbly forever!!!

[themightygit@mstdn.social]

@heyheymomo scribbly, by a large margin.

[amy@sk.girlthi.ng]

@heyheymomo@socel.net the polish is nice but if it’s a lot of work you don’t terribly enjoy (as is the 80/20 rule) then scribbly is still absolutely wonderful

[max@manmachine.me]

oh scribbly for sure

[c0debabe@masto.hackers.town]

@heyheymomo I like the scribbly

[celestiallavendar@icedoatmilk.coffee]

@phasorburn@phasorburn.com @heyheymomo@socel.net Agree, the proportions are better in the polished. Think you could find a happy medium between the two!

[capsulejay@mastodon.world]

@heyheymomo Team Scribbly for me all the way

[angel@sakurajima.social]

@heyheymomo@socel.net scribbly 🩷

[boisdevache@bananachips.club]

@heyheymomo Scribbly!

[heyheymomo@socel.net]

I prefer:

[silvermoon82@wandering.shop]

@heyheymomo
Scribbly feels more soft and huggable. Forg's door, in particular, feels kind of cold in the polished one. All straight lines and hard angles.

[posniewski@mastodon.gamedev.place]

@heyheymomo I think the scribbly one here is better. It has a human touch. The polished style feels more mechanical. There's something about the more open artistic choices made in the scribbly one that I prefer as well (tree density, layout of bottom left panel, desk of bottom right).