Once again I’m asking you; scribbly or polished?

[obot50549535@left-bank.net]

@heyheymomo It concerns me that although I can see they are different, it took me quite some time to see which one is scribbly. I see it now.

[mini_ninja_64@chaos.social]

@heyheymomo scribby

[hexadecimal_bird_wizard@kind.social]

@heyheymomo Scribbly! it's more human/made-by-a-people looking and leans into the cute

[aj@androiddev.social]

@heyheymomo Scribbly forever!!!

[themightygit@mstdn.social]

@heyheymomo scribbly, by a large margin.

[amy@sk.girlthi.ng]

@heyheymomo@socel.net the polish is nice but if it’s a lot of work you don’t terribly enjoy (as is the 80/20 rule) then scribbly is still absolutely wonderful

[max@manmachine.me]

oh scribbly for sure

[c0debabe@masto.hackers.town]

@heyheymomo I like the scribbly

[celestiallavendar@icedoatmilk.coffee]

@phasorburn@phasorburn.com @heyheymomo@socel.net Agree, the proportions are better in the polished. Think you could find a happy medium between the two!

[capsulejay@mastodon.world]

@heyheymomo Team Scribbly for me all the way

[angel@sakurajima.social]

@heyheymomo@socel.net scribbly 🩷

[boisdevache@bananachips.club]

@heyheymomo Scribbly!

[heyheymomo@socel.net]

I prefer:

[silvermoon82@wandering.shop]

@heyheymomo
Scribbly feels more soft and huggable. Forg's door, in particular, feels kind of cold in the polished one. All straight lines and hard angles.

[posniewski@mastodon.gamedev.place]

@heyheymomo I think the scribbly one here is better. It has a human touch. The polished style feels more mechanical. There's something about the more open artistic choices made in the scribbly one that I prefer as well (tree density, layout of bottom left panel, desk of bottom right).

[drahardja@sfba.social]

@heyheymomo I like polished

[aydakikio@mastodon.social]

@heyheymomo
Scribbly

[dreadfu@app.wafrn.net]

@heyheymomo@socel.net @shadows_killer@mastodon.social

im interested in seeing the scribbly panels with the same details as the polished panels if that makes sense its very minor like only one leaf missing in the first panel, one bush in the second panel But i feel like it would make a big difference!

[denofearth@mas.to]

@shadows_killer @heyheymomo
Exactly this! The desk in the last panel is more adorable in the scribbly version than the polished one, which looks to me to be too crisp and mathematical.

Also I love the lilypad carpet in the third panel, and I appreciate how the carpet in the fourth panel is different.

Either way though your art is wonderfully warm and magical, and brings a ray of sunshine that we all desperately need. Thank you!

[oheso@ieji.de]

@heyheymomo I'm a polished.