US judge dismisses murder, weapons charges against alleged CEO killer Luigi Mangione

[lashman@mastodon.social]

@catraxx indeed

[alextecplayz@techhub.social]

@lashman WHAT

"U.S. District Judge Margaret M. Garnett in Manhattan said she dismissed the murder and weapons charges because they were legally incompatible with the two counts of stalking Mangione faces."

Looking into this, the federal murder charges were dismissed as stalking isn't a "crime of violence" under previous precedents. This eliminates the possibility of the death penalty federally (and NY state has no death penalty).

He'll face two counts of stalking in federal court, and the murder charge in a separate state case. The harshest outcome would be life without parole.

[tezoatlipoca@mas.to]

@alextecplayz @lashman

Ah, thanks, didn't understand quite what that meant. Article seemed to imply that any murder charge was off the table entirely.

[alextecplayz@techhub.social]

@tezoatlipoca @lashman I thought so too, but thankfully that doesn't seem to be the case.

[reflex@retrogaming.social]

@lashman Is stalking all that is left? That blurb does not say what remains.

[no5jw@mastodon.social]

@lashman this guy haha hope he walks, I know murder is bad but he just feels like a robinhood to me - no love for giant corporations who deny people treatments to save their lives

[reflex@retrogaming.social]

@spacehobo @lashman So basically the federal case is almost eliminated but he still faces state charges. Thanks that makes sense. Not shocked the state is handling this more competently, but my feeling is a jury won't convict for more than the most minor charges there.

[rasterweb@mastodon.social]

@lashman We need a hip-hop artist called "CEO Killer".

[erik@mastodon.infrageeks.social]

@lashman That was unexpected. But as the judge pointed out, there are so many self-contradictory laws and precedents that this kind of thing happens.

Good to hear the death penalty is now off the table

[caymanpilot@mastodon.social]

@No5JW @lashman
I'm with you

[peachfront@toot.community]

@lashman

it's a start #FreeLuigi

[ricardoharvin@mstdn.social]

@lashman Luigi did nothing wrong, until he lowered his mask while being recorded.

[courtney@dads.cool]

@reflex @spacehobo @lashman also NY doesn't have the death penalty, right? Versus the federal court.

[passwordsarehard4@mastodon.social]

@ricardoharvin @lashman come on now, he got caught with the gun. He did plenty of stuff wrong, like getting caught to start with.

[alexafontanilla2024@mastodon.social]

@No5JW
#PostOfTheWeek (season 3):
Luigi Mangione will not face the death penalty after a U.S. judge on Friday dismissed murder and weapons charges against the accused killer of UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson, in a major blow to federal prosecutors.

[alexafontanilla2024@mastodon.social]

@No5JW
U.S. District Judge Margaret Garnett (Judge of the United States District Court for the Southern District of New York) in Manhattan said she felt constrained by Supreme Court precedents to dismiss the murder charge, saying it was legally incompatible with the two stalking charges Mangione still faces, while acknowledging that ordinary people might be dumbfounded by the outcome.

[ricardoharvin@mstdn.social]

@passwordsarehard4 @lashman Sure, bot

[melioristicmarie@tech.lgbt]

@lashman

[c.e.o. culler]

[sunflowerfield@mastodon.social]

@lashman Good news.

[reflex@retrogaming.social]

@courtney @spacehobo @lashman They do not.