Nobody under age 35 is allowed to vote in this poll

[djdarren@mendeddrum.org]

@jalefkowit Are we talking solo or with Genesis?

Because if it's the former, then my vote is for Gabriel, but if it's the latter then my vote is also for Gabriel.

[chigaze@cosocial.ca]

@jalefkowit Well my playlists include a lot of Gabriel and no Collins so…

[tantramar@zeroes.ca]

@jalefkowit I never saw Phil Collins live. ‍️

[josgeluk@mastodon.nl]

@roygreenhilt it's one o'clock and time for lunch. Dum de dum de dum.

@ArabellaLovejoy @jalefkowit

[alfvaen@mastodon.murkworks.net]

@jalefkowit
Phil Collins in Genesis, Peter Gabriel solo.

[wyatt_h_knott@mstdn.social]

@jalefkowit you're mean

[wyatt_h_knott@mstdn.social]

@jalefkowit This is the classic genx argument. Just look at the comments. When? Before or after the breakup. Solo or together?

I dunno, when were you a teenager?

[a@pdx.social]

@jalefkowit @HollyGoDarkly I voted on the basis of them being a musician in their own right; I would flip my vote if we were asking about their role as a member of Genesis.

[msbellows@c.im]

@jalefkowit Not even close, man.

[hikergeek@mas.to]

@jalefkowit

Peter Gabriel is a brilliant artist with the courage to try new things throughout his whole life. He has studied and incorporated musical styles from around the world. He also has a very good voice.

Phil Collins is a drummer who doesn't get along with other people particularly well.

[raganwald@social.bau-ha.us]

@jalefkowit

[maxwellmercy@c.im]

@jalefkowit So

[nonya_bidniss@infosec.exchange]

@jalefkowit Phil Collins is the Kenny Loggins of Billy Joels

[scrummy@jawns.club]

@gregtitus @jalefkowit But that sound came from Phil’s playing on “Intruder” from PG3!

[workwithkirk@mstdn.social]

@Nonya_Bidniss @jalefkowit And Peter Gabriel is the Bono of Stings.

[nonya_bidniss@infosec.exchange]

@WorkWithKirk @jalefkowit I'll allow it!

[atomicbird@mastodon.social]

@jalefkowit @wndxlori it’s apples and oranges, both good in their own way

[ve2uwy@mastodon.radio]

@jalefkowit

Su su sudio, I mean come on.

[flyingsaceur@ioc.exchange]

@jalefkowit Mandrake, do you recall what Clemenceau said about Motown?

[puffs cigar]

He said Motown is too important to be trusted to the Brits

Peter Gabriel

[mav@masto.hackers.town]

@LeDiva @jalefkowit this is exactly what I'm thinking too.