Platner and The Purity Trap
-
@mastodonmigration @badtux Do you understand how utterly offensive it is to keep labeling refusing to support abusers a 'purity trap'?
This shit is why we lose elections we should win. Nobody believes our rhetoric because we claim moral superiority and then abandon it the moment it *may* cost us an election.
If you don't live in Maine he isn't on your ticket. You have hundreds of important races across the country. You could focus on the ones not running abusers.
-
@FIAR_Light @mastodonmigration And then they blamed 'the left' for Kamala's loss. We told them what to do, we told them to end this genocide and US support for an Apartheid state. They refused and then blamed the consequences of that choice on the people with principles.
@reflex @FIAR_Light @mastodonmigration IMO if both presidential candidates are genocidal, it's in everyone's interest to vote for the less genocidal candidate. It is disgusting, but also utterly true.
The same goes for sex pests, self-dealers, and all of it. You don't have to like it. None of us do.
-
@reflex @FIAR_Light @mastodonmigration IMO if both presidential candidates are genocidal, it's in everyone's interest to vote for the less genocidal candidate. It is disgusting, but also utterly true.
The same goes for sex pests, self-dealers, and all of it. You don't have to like it. None of us do.
@liquor_american @FIAR_Light @mastodonmigration No change comes from this tactic, we just send the message that these things are okay and continue the slide to the right we've been in since Clinton.
And losing elections, we do a LOT of that. Nobody believes in us anymore.
-
@mastodonmigration @badtux Do you understand how utterly offensive it is to keep labeling refusing to support abusers a 'purity trap'?
This shit is why we lose elections we should win. Nobody believes our rhetoric because we claim moral superiority and then abandon it the moment it *may* cost us an election.
If you don't live in Maine he isn't on your ticket. You have hundreds of important races across the country. You could focus on the ones not running abusers.
Unfortunately, every race matters and the Maine Senate race is absolutely crucial because control of the majority hangs in the balance. Harris losing the presidency certainly was a catastrophe. Unfortunately we don't have the luxury of just moving on when the choices are both bad. That's what politics almost always is. The least bad of two bad choices.
So choosing to move on, to not vote, is a choice. And one with consequences.
-
@liquor_american @FIAR_Light @mastodonmigration No change comes from this tactic, we just send the message that these things are okay and continue the slide to the right we've been in since Clinton.
And losing elections, we do a LOT of that. Nobody believes in us anymore.
@reflex @FIAR_Light @mastodonmigration There's another front to fight this war on, and it's within the party.
We're stuck in a two party system. So until we take ownership of one of those parties, we have the same shitty choices. It's actually pretty simple if you look past how frustrating it is.
-
Unfortunately, every race matters and the Maine Senate race is absolutely crucial because control of the majority hangs in the balance. Harris losing the presidency certainly was a catastrophe. Unfortunately we don't have the luxury of just moving on when the choices are both bad. That's what politics almost always is. The least bad of two bad choices.
So choosing to move on, to not vote, is a choice. And one with consequences.
@mastodonmigration @badtux We did this dance in 2018 and 2020. The end result was 2 years of tenuous control, Dems who could not even pass a voting rights act, and who empowered a genocide, and a loss of congress and the return to power of the fascists.
Doing the same thing repeatedly and expecting different results is idiotic. We either establish who we are, JUST AS THE REPUBLICANS HAVE, or we get at best, very temporary gains.
-
@reflex @FIAR_Light @mastodonmigration There's another front to fight this war on, and it's within the party.
We're stuck in a two party system. So until we take ownership of one of those parties, we have the same shitty choices. It's actually pretty simple if you look past how frustrating it is.
@liquor_american @FIAR_Light @mastodonmigration I absolutely agree with this. In WA state where I was a chair and vice chair for six years, I worked with other new leaders to gut the Dems, removing every 'broken stair' from the county and LD orgs. Once we had eliminated the abusers, volunteers more than doubled. We ran candidates to the left, always and ended up taking more seats than ever before in the county, even in red areas.
My friend Shasti Conrad took over the state party afterwards.
-
@mastodonmigration @badtux We did this dance in 2018 and 2020. The end result was 2 years of tenuous control, Dems who could not even pass a voting rights act, and who empowered a genocide, and a loss of congress and the return to power of the fascists.
Doing the same thing repeatedly and expecting different results is idiotic. We either establish who we are, JUST AS THE REPUBLICANS HAVE, or we get at best, very temporary gains.
This line of argument is effectively that it is better let the fascists win than compromise on principles, and we see very clearly the result of that.
-
@liquor_american @FIAR_Light @mastodonmigration I absolutely agree with this. In WA state where I was a chair and vice chair for six years, I worked with other new leaders to gut the Dems, removing every 'broken stair' from the county and LD orgs. Once we had eliminated the abusers, volunteers more than doubled. We ran candidates to the left, always and ended up taking more seats than ever before in the county, even in red areas.
My friend Shasti Conrad took over the state party afterwards.
@liquor_american @FIAR_Light @mastodonmigration Her run as state party chair has led to a supermajority in the legislature and Dems in every single statewide office. And turned out more votes for Kamala in 2024 than for Biden in 2020.
To do this we boxed out and removed 'visionary' and 'inspirational' and 'need this questionable person to win this purple district' candidates regardless of short term consequences.
But it won us the state, and continues to do so.
-
@mastodonmigration @badtux My position is we must actually BE better to win elections sustainably. Compromising our principles for short term gain costs us in the long run, and the past 30 years are proof of that. If we don't rebuild now our losses will only become more catastrophic.
Continuing to pretend we can hold back the tide while compromising on our values increases the cost of doing the real work needed for a sustainable party.
-
@liquor_american @FIAR_Light @mastodonmigration Her run as state party chair has led to a supermajority in the legislature and Dems in every single statewide office. And turned out more votes for Kamala in 2024 than for Biden in 2020.
To do this we boxed out and removed 'visionary' and 'inspirational' and 'need this questionable person to win this purple district' candidates regardless of short term consequences.
But it won us the state, and continues to do so.
@reflex @FIAR_Light @mastodonmigration That's really awesome, and I think you should tell that story every chance you get, especially in settings like this where a lot of like-minded people might not have a unified vision of how to succeed within this messy system.
-
@mastodonmigration @badtux My position is we must actually BE better to win elections sustainably. Compromising our principles for short term gain costs us in the long run, and the past 30 years are proof of that. If we don't rebuild now our losses will only become more catastrophic.
Continuing to pretend we can hold back the tide while compromising on our values increases the cost of doing the real work needed for a sustainable party.
Right, so for you it is better to lose than compromise your principles, even if the opponent is worse. That is a logically consistent position.
-
@reflex @FIAR_Light @mastodonmigration That's really awesome, and I think you should tell that story every chance you get, especially in settings like this where a lot of like-minded people might not have a unified vision of how to succeed within this messy system.
@liquor_american @reflex @FIAR_Light
Agreed.
-
@mastodonmigration @badtux Again, it is my position that taking short term hits builds a long term movement. And we need a long term movement, not one senate seat this one time.
Most of the time these men turn out to be pretenders anyway. Do you *really* think a privileged white boy who talked online about joining the military rather than going to college to kill people, has an active kik account and is a sex pest is going to be better than Fetterman? He won't.
-
@reflex @FIAR_Light @mastodonmigration That's really awesome, and I think you should tell that story every chance you get, especially in settings like this where a lot of like-minded people might not have a unified vision of how to succeed within this messy system.
@liquor_american @FIAR_Light @mastodonmigration This is the 'inspirational young leader' that united us to clean things up. We were told repeatedly we were kneecapping the party by fighting to remove him and his allies.
https://www.kuow.org/stories/chair-king-county-democrats-resigns-amidst-harassment-investigation/
Instead it lead to a party renaissance that is still growing, even if it made our party completely broken for a while and cost us some elections that year.
It was an investment in a sustainable future.
-
@liquor_american @FIAR_Light @mastodonmigration This is the 'inspirational young leader' that united us to clean things up. We were told repeatedly we were kneecapping the party by fighting to remove him and his allies.
https://www.kuow.org/stories/chair-king-county-democrats-resigns-amidst-harassment-investigation/
Instead it lead to a party renaissance that is still growing, even if it made our party completely broken for a while and cost us some elections that year.
It was an investment in a sustainable future.
@liquor_american @FIAR_Light @mastodonmigration This was the team that we organized to rebuild:
Shasti is now state party chair and the leaders we developed have taken over many local party orgs, several seats in the legislature and many other positions where they continue the values we stood for, again despite the temporary losses our initial takeover resulted in.
-
@mastodonmigration @badtux Again, it is my position that taking short term hits builds a long term movement. And we need a long term movement, not one senate seat this one time.
Most of the time these men turn out to be pretenders anyway. Do you *really* think a privileged white boy who talked online about joining the military rather than going to college to kill people, has an active kik account and is a sex pest is going to be better than Fetterman? He won't.
Understood. In this case you think it is better in the long run that the Democrats do not win the Senate majority than elect Platner. In 2024 it was better that Trump win than elect Harris due to her support for Israel. In the long run these defeats will make the party better. Again, that is a logical position. A lot of people will suffer for it, but it is not an inconsistent stance. It is also precisely why purity traps are so effective.
-
Understood. In this case you think it is better in the long run that the Democrats do not win the Senate majority than elect Platner. In 2024 it was better that Trump win than elect Harris due to her support for Israel. In the long run these defeats will make the party better. Again, that is a logical position. A lot of people will suffer for it, but it is not an inconsistent stance. It is also precisely why purity traps are so effective.
@mastodonmigration @badtux It's not about electing Platner or not. It's about putting our resources into candidates who uphold our stated party values. It's about those values demonstrating the importance of the humanity of each and every person we claim to be representing, in full.
Again, it works, it can cause short term pain, but you know what we don't have in WA now? Back and forth districts. We have gained every single election, even ones where Reps were ascendant nationally.
-
@FIAR_Light @liquor_american @mastodonmigration I posted this in another part of the thread, but this was required reading for the board of any org I ran (Julia Reed, former third vice chair of KC Dems and now state leg representative sent it to me) to understand how broken stairs and moral compromise ruin organizations: https://truthout.org/articles/why-misogynists-make-great-informants/
It's not really about 'informants' per say, it's how misogynists/bigots/etc are indistinguishable from informants in the corrosiveness of their impact.
-
@mastodonmigration The Purity Trap is enabled primarily by the Purity Ponies, single-issue persons who will spend hours arguing with you that issue X totally disqualifies a politician. For example Kamala didn't come out immediately saying that Jews were Nazis exterminating Palestinians so that totally disqualified Kamala from being President. Despite the multitude of other reasons she would have been a better President than the orange underwear skidmark. #PurityPony #fail #politics
@badtux @mastodonmigration I wouldn't call them single-issue persons. Because it's not just a single issue with them. They will switch to whatever is the only important issue as the reason to not vote for the Democrat in the next upcoming election.
And also, this single issue which is supposedly so important will NOT apply to the Republican opponent. It doesn't matter how much worse the Republican opponent is on this supposedly important issue.
