@heyheymomo This is hard to choose, both look really great. I think I mostly prefer the scribbly one, but there are some elements in the frames/composition that I prefer from the polished one.

I hope my reply isn't too detailed, also keep in mind this is just my personal opinion, but:

Frame 1: definitely scribbly, because it's more zoomed out, it has a sun and looks less cramped.

Frame 2: the scribbly house (the face on it looks cuter) and the cloud (the polished one looks more like a star?), but I'd add the bushes from the polished one.

Frame 3: this is difficult! I think generally the scribbly one. but personally it bothers me that the door and window are very different from the 2nd frame (proportions, the door doesn't have the small arched window on top, the window has too many panels)

Frame 4: scribbly one (the laptop looks better. In the polished one I don't get what the blue strip on the monitor is supposed to be and the mouse looks too circly), but I think I prefer the lily pad from the polished one over the blue carpet, fits more to the frog theme and to frame 3.

In any way I love this comic, it's super cute and it made me start the day with a smile Thank you for making these comics!