@steeph @Amoshias part of it has to do with American culture - anything with an English accent can often be considered "high-falutin" by some, and Renaissance-era English especially so. There's also the reality that most of us are exposed to Shakespeare first on the written page, where tone and fluency can't be conveyed. Hearing it spoken by good actors is a totally different experience.
I was lucky to have an enthusiastic and effective Shakespeare teacher in high school. He and I could barely stand to be around one another due to personality issues, but he did manage to convey to me a love for the form.