In a moment when #democracy and self-determination are attacked from so many sides, and authoritarianism and imperialism are again on the rise, I would expect unity among all those who may disagree on many things, but still agree on some basic axioms o...

[fabio@manganiello.eu]

In a moment when #democracy and self-determination are attacked from so many sides, and authoritarianism and imperialism are again on the rise, I would expect unity among all those who may disagree on many things, but still agree on some basic axioms of civilization:

• That a democratic framework and the respect of sovereignty and human dignity should not be negotiable.

• That nobody should be subject to prejudice.

• That nobody should aggressively grab someone else’s lands or resources, no matter how powerful they are.

• That #fascism is always a cancer to eradicate.

Instead, I am seeing divisions along partisan lines.

“Why Ukraine and not Gaza?”

“Why Gaza and not Ukraine?”

“Why Gaza and not Venezuela?”

“Why Greenland but not Iran?”

And so on, for all the possible combinations of whataboutism.

I would have never thought to write a post to state the obvious and call out partisan whataboutism, but here I am. So before anyone writes another “but why does Fabio or <put-the-name-of-a-woke-leftist-liberal-here> support X and doesn’t say anything about Y?”, read these lines and think twice:

• What #Israel has done and keeps doing in #Gaza is an inexcusable genocide. Its perpetrators must be called accountable, Israel must rebuild what it has destroyed no matter the costs, maximum external pressure through boycotts must be applied to all the productive sectors of Israel’s economy, settlers must evacuate all the occupied territories, buffer zones must be set up to prevent any further aggression from either side, and the UN is the only entity legally allowed to control those buffer zones. And all the conditions that have led to such an apartheid State must be dismantled one by one.

• #Hamas is a terrorist group. They must be called accountable for two decades of terror and restrictions imposed to Gazans, they must go and new elections must be held as soon as it’s feasible. But they must not go through a permanent military occupation, and not by murdering, displacing and/or starving 2M people. #Palestine has its right to flourish. Without Hamas, and without Israeli colonizers.

• What #Russia has done to #Ukraine is an inexcusable imperialist invasion. It must release all territories invaded since 2014, pay for reconstruction, #Putin must be arrested as soon as he sets his foot in any country that recognizes the authority of the ICJ, maximum pressure through sanctions and boycotts must be applied to everything Russia touches, and buffer zones controlled by the UN must be prepared in order to prevent any further aggression.

• What #Trump is doing to #Venezuela is a grave imperialist attack motivated by nothing else but personal greed and geopolitical games. He must be called accountable for this (and for hundreds of other crimes against his citizens and humanity), all free nations have a civic duty of decoupling themselves from such a rogue actor and isolate #America, and Trump’s life must end in a jail.

• What #Maduro has done to #Venezuela and to its people is outrageous. Very few leaders in the past 50 years have been as corrupt, inept and arrogant as him. He literally sits on a mine of easily reachable oil, and yet he couldn’t even make a coherent plan to dig it that wasn’t rotten in cronyism and corruption from its very start. He has cheated so badly at the latest elections that it was one of the few cases where a simple analysis of the probability of the results could mathematically prove that they were faked. He must go, but not through Uncle Sam suddenly bombing his city, kidnapping him like a thug, jailing him in a country that has no legal jurisdiction over him, and installing whatever puppet could hand him all the oil instead. If you are outraged at Putin for repeatedly trying to install friendly puppets in all former Soviet territories, then you ought to also be outraged at America for repeatedly trying to install friendly puppets in Central and South America.

• What #China threatens to do against #Taiwan is outrageous and the world must firmly condemn it, recognize Taiwan’s legitimacy as an independent sovereign country that should develop without the constant threat of Chinese unilateral aggression, and world leaders should provide support to it by explicitly threatening military action against China if it decides to violate Taiwan’s sovereignty.

• What Iranian citizens are doing against their decrepit regime is an act of bravery that must be fully supported. The Iranian regime has brought nothing upon its wonderful and smart people but misery, restrictions, bigotry, terror and isolation, and it must go. If its own citizens protest, we must throw our full support at them, until the regime falls. But you don’t make the regime fall by simply bombing Teheran. The only thing you achieve by doing that is uniting both the regime and its citizens in their rage against your bombs - which is exactly the opposite of what you want to achieve. Westerners should already have learned in 1979 that any attempts to meddle with the will of #Iran and its people backfires very badly.

• #Greenland is a sovereign territory that is still in the course of building its own autonomy from Denmark. Asking (or even worse threatening) its people to jump from one colonizer to another is as vulgar as publicly asking a woman coming out of an abusive relationship to have sex with you. But of course this is exactly the kind of vulgarity that you’d expect from an unhinged moral pervert like Trump. The world should not give a single fuck about America’s security needs, whether real or fictional, when the price for them is colonialist expansion. You can’t buy territories at the supermarket. You can’t coerce them into selling themselves to you. This is not RisiKo. Self-determination must always be respected. If you’re worried about your security, try to behave less like a sociopath jerk and have less enemies. Try to embrace multilateralism and dialogue rather than coercion and authoritarianism. It helps, you’ll see.

Let me know if I missed anything from this list.

I hope that the stance is clear and whataboutism is neutralized.

Defending the oppressed and condeming the oppressors is not a partisan political game. It’s not a question of being pro or against Israel, America, Russia, Venezuela, China, Taiwan, Ukraine, Iran, Hamas or whatever. Geopolitical narratives may put the oppressed on opposite sides of partisan lines. International law and the philosophical framework that underpins our civilization since the Enlightenment, instead, put them exactly on the same side.

When you throw whataboutism at someone who is enraged about someone bullied by an imperialist fascist, just because that episode of bullyism isn’t something that you’re particularly sensitive on, and you want to draw the spotlight on someone else you’re more sympathetic with, then you’re a filthy imperialist fascist too.

If you hate a fascist thug then you hate all of them. And if you don’t hate all the fascist thugs from the bottom of your heart then you’re one of them too.