Where is the self?
-
-
@evan Everywhere.
Like, Dude.
-
@evan Everywhere.
Like, Dude.
@davep humour me
-
@evan Nowhere to be found
-
@evan combination of brain and body
-
@evan combination of brain and body
@julesbl the brain is part of the body
-
@davep humour me
@evan Done
-
@julesbl the brain is part of the body
@evan
For a long time the rest of the body has been left out of this discussion despite the massive impact it has on who we are and how we think -
@evan Somewhere in the Objective-C runtime that runs the universe.
-
@evan in the community
-
@evan I really think guts! but I picked brain from the choices.
-
@evan Tough one! Brain is _very important_ but it doesn't exist in a vacuum, it's affected by the rest of the body with its hormone productions and its biofeedback loops to the outside world.
For poll purposes I feel like I have to pick "the brain" but with an asterisk for ", but..."
*voted*
-
@evan the body brain continuum
Without the sensorium of the body would there be a self?
-
@evan missing the real answer: the stomach and intestines
-
I vote the spirit I don't believe in physics / logic-execution being enough for consciousness, so I have to think it my "self" is something else. Though I guess this reasoning doesn't necessarily exclude the idea of particles having some sort of transcendental quality which consciousness comes from....
-
@evan the body brain continuum
Without the sensorium of the body would there be a self?
@smallcircles
Yeah, I can make a case for "all of the above", but without the central nervous system, at least for humans, there is no "self".
@evan -
@evan Body and soul together.
-
@evan I really think guts! but I picked brain from the choices.
@maj you're the guts
-
@maj you're the guts
@evan I contain multitudes (of diverse gut bacteria that might be at least partly responsible for the illusion of a continuous self!)
-
@evan I picked heart. It is the closest to what I actually believe, which is the center of the gut just a few centimeters below the navel, inside the body. Some theories believe the thinking part ("the brain") of the nervous system is mostly interpreting and telling a story about the behavior we decide on a more intutive level (gut feeling). Michael Gazzaniga's study of the interpreter function is famous for this.
