this graduation speech moment is notable, and her amazed shock at having failed to read the room feels instructive.
-
@cabel Here, too, you’re in an “AI-hater” bubble, but AI is here to stay—just as smashing machines didn’t stop the Industrial Revolution.
-
@danbrotherston @cabel Just like AI haters aren’t opposed to the environmental and financial impacts of AI; they’re simply afraid of being replaced and don’t want to learn new skills.
No. Environmental destruction, resource capture, profiling and political advertising are all reasons for people hating AI.
-
I can't imagine "the internet" getting boo'd like that in 2001 Grads would have cheered along for "internet"
Or even like bitcoin in say 2010, lots of people were skeptical but would not have just boo'd
This is remarkably unpopular.
@futurebird @cabel Well, I guess there are quite a few people in the audience who have been told that their just received diplomas may be decorative on their bedroom walls, but will not give them access to rewarding, well-paid jobs like they were promised 4 years ago ... soooooo ...
-
You had about half a dozen chances to participate in a calm and meaningful discussion and you blew all of them.
I'm glad that this is quite a rare exception in the #Fediverse and I truly hope it stays like this.
So how about you join in and come up with some arguments instead of calling sceptics haters?
@cabel @danbrotherston @pontus_k @tribactam @gulfie @Mikal @SmartmanApps @skjeggtroll @rubixhelix
-
@danbrotherston @cabel Just like AI haters aren’t opposed to the environmental and financial impacts of AI; they’re simply afraid of being replaced and don’t want to learn new skills.
@howking @danbrotherston @cabel actually we hate the whole range of pointless problems that AI is creating for us. -
@cabel Here, too, you’re in an “AI-hater” bubble, but AI is here to stay—just as smashing machines didn’t stop the Industrial Revolution.
-
@cabel Here, too, you’re in an “AI-hater” bubble, but AI is here to stay—just as smashing machines didn’t stop the Industrial Revolution.
@cabel AI hate sentiment is just as much of a pose as anti-vax. It’s a herd mentality—joining a group of people who don’t understand this any better than I do.
-
@raymaccarthy @cabel Not very well at first.
-
@howking @cabel @danbrotherston @gulfie @Mikal @SmartmanApps @skjeggtroll Nigga why you look like gargamel from the smurfs
-
@danbrotherston @howking @cabel Not only were the Luddites not against the machinery, many of them were MASTER USERS OF IT. Exactly as you said, the protest wasn't against machinery but against what it was doing to entire societies.
And it's the same fight today.
@ZDL @danbrotherston @howking @cabel
The owners were making 1000 to 10000 times more profit from the workers, but giving less pay and poorer conditions, though more people had jobs.It was not about the machines, but objecting to greed.
The AI LLM is different:
The providers are not actually making a profit.
Contentious that the companies using make more money,
It may not work well.
A few providers.
Content often illegally obtained.
The marketing is lies. -
@ZDL @danbrotherston @howking @cabel
The owners were making 1000 to 10000 times more profit from the workers, but giving less pay and poorer conditions, though more people had jobs.It was not about the machines, but objecting to greed.
The AI LLM is different:
The providers are not actually making a profit.
Contentious that the companies using make more money,
It may not work well.
A few providers.
Content often illegally obtained.
The marketing is lies.@raymaccarthy @danbrotherston @howking @cabel Well, yes. The unmitigated failure of LLM technology to actually turn a profit is also a strong rejoinder to "this is the next industrial revolution".
What I'm always pondering is "What examples of world-changing technology in the past has required people to force it into other people's maws to get it used?"
The closest I can get to is vaccination, and that was a very different situation.
-
@SmartmanApps @GhostOnTheHalfShell @cabel but it kind of does? i mean theres mathematicians acknowledging its generating some pretty decent proofs of previously unsolved stuff and so forth. i dont see why people are always clinging to these by now obviously false claims of inaptitude when the issues are much more standard capitalism type
@uniwuni @GhostOnTheHalfShell @cabel
" it kind of does?" - no, it totally doesn't"its generating some pretty decent proofs" - worded proofs, but as we've seen repeatedly https://dotnet.social/@SmartmanApps/116000100388648367
it will often SAY the right thing to do, then not do it, because it doesn't understand what those words mean. Witness where it says "inside the brackets", but removes the brackets, and in algebra applies what it says to one side of the equation only, instead of both sides (and concludes "1=0"
) -
I can't imagine "the internet" getting boo'd like that in 2001 Grads would have cheered along for "internet"
Or even like bitcoin in say 2010, lots of people were skeptical but would not have just boo'd
This is remarkably unpopular.
@futurebird @cabel Notable too, her next line, "A few years ago, A.I. was not a factor in our lives" *does* get cheered, so they're clearly not out for the speaker themselves, but the specific message.
As opposed to people who thought Conservatives were confused when they cheered when one of the Conservative speakers was say "Do you want impeachment?", and was not expecting the cheering then either...and figured they could point out that they were *supposed* to be opposed to another impeachment of Trump this recent year.
-
@uniwuni @GhostOnTheHalfShell @cabel
" it kind of does?" - no, it totally doesn't"its generating some pretty decent proofs" - worded proofs, but as we've seen repeatedly https://dotnet.social/@SmartmanApps/116000100388648367
it will often SAY the right thing to do, then not do it, because it doesn't understand what those words mean. Witness where it says "inside the brackets", but removes the brackets, and in algebra applies what it says to one side of the equation only, instead of both sides (and concludes "1=0" )@uniwuni @GhostOnTheHalfShell @cabel
"obviously false claims of inaptitude" - nope. See my thread for the proof of it's ineptitude at Maths -
@cabel @ShaulaEvans I'm guessing those grads have discovered what the job market is like, since AI-related layoffs.
@deborahh @cabel @ShaulaEvans Don't even need to discover - just need to have seen the result from others in the market, or just...have heard enough about LLMs to be opposed to them.
-
@waderoberts @cabel Knuth and Torvalds are notable exceptions.
-
this graduation speech moment is notable, and her amazed shock at having failed to read the room feels instructive.
when you’re inside the bubble, you think everybody else is. but everybody isn’t.
Type 1 AI Psychosis
-
@waderoberts @cabel I mean, I'm impressed. They do perform much better than I would have expected based just on general understanding how an LLM works.
Which is not at all to say I'm in any way impressed by their ability to perform the tasks the "AI" evangelists proclaim it's good for.
-
@futurebird
Proponents are always comparing it to the industrial revolution, but maybe it's better compared to the likes of leaded gasoline, CFC aerosol cans, or asbestos anything.Maybe some of us have learned to spot a pattern.
@cabel@Landa @futurebird @cabel I think asbestos is quite perfect comparison.
-
this graduation speech moment is notable, and her amazed shock at having failed to read the room feels instructive.
when you’re inside the bubble, you think everybody else is. but everybody isn’t.
@cabel drank too much A1 sauce / koolaid
