@fdroidorg please don't.
-
@IzzyOnDroid @fdroidorg Hmm....
"One should never forget: the people who control access to #GenAI technology today, will tomorrow be the ones who exercise total control over #FOSS projects which embrace GenAI."
Can you please elaborate a bit on *how* do you this expect to happen?
@theron29 @IzzyOnDroid @fdroidorg There are decent enough local or independently hosted LLM already.
-
@fdroidorg please don't. It was disappointing enough with Debian already:
https://gitlab.com/fdroid/admin/-/work_items/699
One should never forget: the people who control access to #GenAI technology today, will tomorrow be the ones who exercise total control over #FOSS projects which embrace GenAI.
We can tell first hand, that setting up a policy for that is not done overnight. But you could at least "strongly discourage" until you have one, no, #FDroid ?
@IzzyOnDroid reject AI LLMs, @fdroidorg
-
@fdroidorg please don't. It was disappointing enough with Debian already:
https://gitlab.com/fdroid/admin/-/work_items/699
One should never forget: the people who control access to #GenAI technology today, will tomorrow be the ones who exercise total control over #FOSS projects which embrace GenAI.
We can tell first hand, that setting up a policy for that is not done overnight. But you could at least "strongly discourage" until you have one, no, #FDroid ?
@IzzyOnDroid @fdroidorg if F-Droid adopts the Debian policy, i will stop using F-Droid. simple as.
-
@IzzyOnDroid @fdroidorg if F-Droid adopts the Debian policy, i will stop using F-Droid. simple as.
@GroupNebula563 @IzzyOnDroid @fdroidorg
Thinking of the same. But are there any alternatives, yet?
-
@fdroidorg please don't. It was disappointing enough with Debian already:
https://gitlab.com/fdroid/admin/-/work_items/699
One should never forget: the people who control access to #GenAI technology today, will tomorrow be the ones who exercise total control over #FOSS projects which embrace GenAI.
We can tell first hand, that setting up a policy for that is not done overnight. But you could at least "strongly discourage" until you have one, no, #FDroid ?
Another once-respected FOSS project slams the self-destruct button.
Is *anything* going to survive the Great #FOSS Apocalypse of 2026?
-
Another once-respected FOSS project slams the self-destruct button.
Is *anything* going to survive the Great #FOSS Apocalypse of 2026?
@argv_minus_one @IzzyOnDroid @fdroidorg
I recently made a decision to use Debian over Ubuntu for server installations, but now I'm not sure what to do. Ubuntu, being Debian based, is not an option to return to, and I don't know which other distributions to trust. It's going to take time to see how this all shakes out, I guess. -
How the heck could any use of AI agents be considered “very careful” when AI agents do stuff like this: https://www.pcmag.com/news/vibe-coding-fiasco-replite-ai-agent-goes-rogue-deletes-company-database
-
@theron29 Let me just drop a few keywords on that: token price, how the LLMs are trained, how they direct/influence those using them.
Sorry, I won't write a book on that
Have to attend my maintenance tasks…@IzzyOnDroid That is nice and all, but I'm sorry to say that that does not really explain on hot that shall "take over" the FOSS projects:
Why? E.g. because nobody is forcing FOSS developers into using AI; they are still free to develop their projects the way they want...
Also, by using AI for sw development those projects do not owe anything to anyone; they are free to start and/or stop using AI any way they want, any time...
On top of that, there are open LLM models available too...
-
@IzzyOnDroid That is nice and all, but I'm sorry to say that that does not really explain on hot that shall "take over" the FOSS projects:
Why? E.g. because nobody is forcing FOSS developers into using AI; they are still free to develop their projects the way they want...
Also, by using AI for sw development those projects do not owe anything to anyone; they are free to start and/or stop using AI any way they want, any time...
On top of that, there are open LLM models available too...
@theron29 Oh, drug addicts are also free to leave anytime. They just can't anymore.
And yes, one might differ between BigCorpLLM, and libre/local models. My stance goes against the former, not the latter.
-
Another once-respected FOSS project slams the self-destruct button.
Is *anything* going to survive the Great #FOSS Apocalypse of 2026?
@argv_minus_one We shall hope so!
-
@GroupNebula563 @IzzyOnDroid @fdroidorg
Thinking of the same. But are there any alternatives, yet?
@munter @GroupNebula563 not at that scale, no. Would you like this one? https://izzyondroid.org/docs/general/AppInclusionPolicy/#ai-policy (still not finalized – but you need to start from somewhere) Unfortunately has the side effect of many inclusion request to be declined, because of… well, genAI…
-
@munter @GroupNebula563 not at that scale, no. Would you like this one? https://izzyondroid.org/docs/general/AppInclusionPolicy/#ai-policy (still not finalized – but you need to start from somewhere) Unfortunately has the side effect of many inclusion request to be declined, because of… well, genAI…
@IzzyOnDroid yes please! Decline those apps!
-
@IzzyOnDroid yes please! Decline those apps!
@IzzyOnDroid (and in case it needs to be said, as a user, I would rather you remove the exceptions for documentation and the like!)
-
@GroupNebula563 @IzzyOnDroid @fdroidorg
Thinking of the same. But are there any alternatives, yet?
-
@IzzyOnDroid (and in case it needs to be said, as a user, I would rather you remove the exceptions for documentation and the like!)
@tjk Heh, are you an LLM? That is what Gemini said. Someone fed our policy to it for a summary, and that thing put as verdict, we'd be inconsequential – and should remove those exceptions as well
NB: Gemini totally missed the point. What you do in your sphere, is outside our jurisdiction – and not for us to say. That policy represents OUR house rules, not yours. So it's about what enters OUR house – not what you served as side dish in yours. We might not like it, but we're not your judges.
-
@tjk Heh, are you an LLM? That is what Gemini said. Someone fed our policy to it for a summary, and that thing put as verdict, we'd be inconsequential – and should remove those exceptions as well
NB: Gemini totally missed the point. What you do in your sphere, is outside our jurisdiction – and not for us to say. That policy represents OUR house rules, not yours. So it's about what enters OUR house – not what you served as side dish in yours. We might not like it, but we're not your judges.
@IzzyOnDroid i don't understand your response. I don't use LLMs. I use your repos (thank you!) and I think it'd be better to exclude any work done with AI. I was glad to see your policy forbidding them for code, but I'd like even more if it were stronger, without the exceptions.
-
@argv_minus_one @IzzyOnDroid @fdroidorg
I recently made a decision to use Debian over Ubuntu for server installations, but now I'm not sure what to do. Ubuntu, being Debian based, is not an option to return to, and I don't know which other distributions to trust. It's going to take time to see how this all shakes out, I guess.@bruce
This is what I know of, at present:
https://mastodon.online/@Brett_E_Carlock/117176296434543250They all share the now-tainted kernel and many other libraries, but some improvement is better than none.
-
M marcusxms@helvede.net shared this topic
