New blog post "License update: AI derivation prohibited on all my art, lore, stories, and comics."→ https://www.davidrevoy.com/article1178/license-update-ai-derivation-prohibited-on-all-my-art-lore-stories-and-comics
-
@cwebber @davidrevoy Isn't this what CC BY-ND is for?
@dajb @cwebber @davidrevoy I'd think it would be easier to start with CC BY-ND and then add an exception to allow for derivatives if they were not AI.
However, I am not a lawyer. Also: possession is nine-tenths of the law, and the AI companies have already trained on the data.
Laws, contracts and licenses are only useful if all parties actually agree to the terms. The written text of the licenses is really only to avoid confusion about the agreement. But the AI companies don't show good faith.
-
@h5e @davidrevoy I agree, it's deranged.
@f4grx @h5e @davidrevoy
Since I'm not actually deranged (externally verified), the very notion of feeding someone else's work into an Ai to "improve" or "expand" it brings on a powerful retch reflex.Seems about as acceptable as raping a sheep on the town square at midday.
-
New blog post "License update: AI derivation prohibited on all my art, lore, stories, and comics."
→ https://www.davidrevoy.com/article1178/license-update-ai-derivation-prohibited-on-all-my-art-lore-stories-and-comics@davidrevoy There is zero emotion in the AI rendering... the kids looks asleep and the cat looks dead...
-
New blog post "License update: AI derivation prohibited on all my art, lore, stories, and comics."
→ https://www.davidrevoy.com/article1178/license-update-ai-derivation-prohibited-on-all-my-art-lore-stories-and-comics@davidrevoy its so sad that ppl send you ai gen stuff and think you would like it.. especially you are always openly against it.
Thanks you so much again for making this beautiful pieces of real art
-
New blog post "License update: AI derivation prohibited on all my art, lore, stories, and comics."
→ https://www.davidrevoy.com/article1178/license-update-ai-derivation-prohibited-on-all-my-art-lore-stories-and-comics@davidrevoy Might want to have https://slashpages.net/#ai redirect to your blog post
-
New blog post "License update: AI derivation prohibited on all my art, lore, stories, and comics."
→ https://www.davidrevoy.com/article1178/license-update-ai-derivation-prohibited-on-all-my-art-lore-stories-and-comics@davidrevoy This is news-worthy.
-
@davidrevoy I'm 100% with you on this. All power to you! I hope things will get better for you.
For my own software I had a clause "You are not allowed to use this software to train your LLM" until Guillem Jover (dpkg) pointed out that this would make my software non-free in the eyes of the Debian Free Software Guidelines and other definitions of free software (use for any endeavor).
It's a pity that the principles on which free software was founded decades ago can now be used against it.
@josch I've had a non free license on my web site for years, and I don't think it even slows down big-LLM, even if it gives me some small satisfaction.
Edit: this just CC-*-NC, which won't help the OP. @davidrevoy
-
@davidrevoy HELLING FUK THE ARM!!
@efi @davidrevoy jfc i totally missed that (between the chubbier everything and the way her expression is totally changed and now it's like she's just waiting for you to throw a peanut in her mouth) -
@efi @davidrevoy jfc i totally missed that (between the chubbier everything and the way her expression is totally changed and now it's like she's just waiting for you to throw a peanut in her mouth)@efi @davidrevoy (and the three knees)
-
New blog post "License update: AI derivation prohibited on all my art, lore, stories, and comics."
→ https://www.davidrevoy.com/article1178/license-update-ai-derivation-prohibited-on-all-my-art-lore-stories-and-comics@davidrevoy
I read yesterday that some scientists/researchers want to sue #OpenAI for using #data from their collective work to feed their #AI machine to crack a long-known conundrum. -
@davidrevoy Glad you are doing something, a little uncertain what the license is exactly. But also, I kind of suspect, all of this stuff is a violation of even CC BY if these licenses were actually enforced and the other FOSS orgs who might have influenced things hadn't dropped the ball; there's simply no way to preserve the "attribution soup" of these works...
Meanwhile at Creative Commons:
https://github.com/creativecommons/cc-signals/discussionsThese used to be issues. Also the protest fell on deaf ears.
I'm sorry but CC won't be on your side here
-
Meanwhile at Creative Commons:
https://github.com/creativecommons/cc-signals/discussionsThese used to be issues. Also the protest fell on deaf ears.
I'm sorry but CC won't be on your side here
@RyunoKi @davidrevoy CC the institution, maybe not. But the legalcode still requires attribution.
-
New blog post "License update: AI derivation prohibited on all my art, lore, stories, and comics."
→ https://www.davidrevoy.com/article1178/license-update-ai-derivation-prohibited-on-all-my-art-lore-stories-and-comics@davidrevoy Honestly, we need a CC-NOAI license.
-
New blog post "License update: AI derivation prohibited on all my art, lore, stories, and comics."
→ https://www.davidrevoy.com/article1178/license-update-ai-derivation-prohibited-on-all-my-art-lore-stories-and-comics@davidrevoy I feel your pain. The original sketch is so wonderful. I love how you drew the cat. I feel really uncomfortable with the way AI generates pictures. I like human-y things.
-
@efi @davidrevoy (and the three knees)
@ophis @davidrevoy or she's trans now
-
@RyunoKi @davidrevoy CC the institution, maybe not. But the legalcode still requires attribution.
@cwebber @davidrevoy True.
But unless it produces art verbatim (whatever that means?) it's going to be tough to win in court, I guess.
I mean, you have large newspapers in US taking OpenAI to court. Just to have DOJ side with the latter.
Expressing the wish to not be vacuumed up is better than nothing.
-
New blog post "License update: AI derivation prohibited on all my art, lore, stories, and comics."
→ https://www.davidrevoy.com/article1178/license-update-ai-derivation-prohibited-on-all-my-art-lore-stories-and-comics@davidrevoy I suppose I shoudn't be surprised that someone sent you AI-generated episodes for the Avian Intelligence series, but damn...they really missed the point, didn't they?
-
@ophis @davidrevoy or she's trans now
@efi @davidrevoy or he is (given what hrt does i'm going to assume this is one hell of a phalloplasty) -
New blog post "License update: AI derivation prohibited on all my art, lore, stories, and comics."
→ https://www.davidrevoy.com/article1178/license-update-ai-derivation-prohibited-on-all-my-art-lore-stories-and-comics@davidrevoy Your situation seems terrifying. I can't imagine the feeling of receiving such things like as it was 'normal'.
Seeing artists suffering from this makes me boil in anger. Hope your adjustements will have at least minimum effects. Sending support your way for dealing wih all this bs.
-
New blog post "License update: AI derivation prohibited on all my art, lore, stories, and comics."
→ https://www.davidrevoy.com/article1178/license-update-ai-derivation-prohibited-on-all-my-art-lore-stories-and-comics@davidrevoy
As someone who's trying to build a new music platform centered around CC licenses and local communities, I thank you for writing the article. I 100% concur.My research shows that unfortunately, it's difficult for any license at all to restrict AI training on content, because that's a copyright issue, not a licensing one. I'm hoping that this will change. I want to protect local and independent musicians from AI theft, but I want them to share w/CC and be supported, too. It's hard.
